Our Shark Tank audition experience

Baby Paper as Shark Bait

No, you are probably not going to see Baby Paper on Shark Tank.  We did peak the curiosity of the casting members enough to get to round two, which in Shark Tank speak means that they asked for a video.

The journey began with an email from Comcast Business announcing a last minute decision by Shark Tank to hold a casting call in Comcast's new storefront in Chicago.  I arrived for a 10:00 a.m. door opening at 6:00 a.m., only to find the line already wrapped around the building and into the neighborhood.  The instructions said that the first 500 people would obtain a bracelet which would grant a few minutes in front of a casting associate.  Oh, the relief when I was given the golden ticket (bracelet).

The whole process is very organized (I guess they've done this a few times).  Potential contestants are brought in, in groups of 50.  The Casting Director then gives instructions and insight into what to expect once you are granted your few moments.

He was brutally honest and actually very funny in telling our group that the odds are slim that any of us will make it past this point.  He basically said, enjoy this today and assume that you won't hear from us.  We were also treated to what was equivalent to a live commercial for Comcast Business.

If you know our product, you know that we do not sell direct to the consumer nor are we interested in selling to big box retailers or direct to Amazon.  We believe in supporting local merchants (they can sell on Amazon).  We fully support organizations such as ASTRA and Brixy

that work hard to help keep our neighborhood stores in business.

When my number was called, I was ushered behind a curtain, where a makeshift casting room was set up.  There were several casting associates at a long table and eager entrepreneurs doing their best to set themselves apart.  You are literally just feet away from another contestant while making your own pitch.

I stood before a very weary associate, who had just been given some lunch.  She looked at me and asked if I minded if she ate during my pitch, which of course, I didn't.  I gave a brief description of Baby Paper and how it came to be.  I mentioned our commitment to local merchants and she looked up from her salad to comment on that.  I gave my soapbox speech about the need to support local businesses so that they can support our communities.  She said thank you and I was released.

As instructed by the Casting Director, I assumed that my journey began and ended that day.  I did love talking to the others in line and figured it was definitely not a run-of-the mill kind of day.

So, when the phone call came I was in a bit of shock.  Just seeing the email with the news "Congrats on making it to the video submission round" was cause for celebration.  That and a lot of scrambling to get a video done professionally and quickly.

According to the rules in the extremely long email, and tucked at the very bottom of said email, was this line:

"From this point forward you are not allowed to discuss your status with anyone.  THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT…Absolutely NO blogging, tweeting, facebooking etc."

Needless to say, that by the time I read through the video instructions and legalities, I was halfway through a bottle of wine and had already texted, emailed and shouted about my accomplishment.  Within hours, and through a modern age telephone game, I was not only into round two, rumors were flying that I was already headed to LA for my debut.  In reality, only the video and Baby Paper samples were headed to LA!  We even had "Mr Wonderful" custom Baby Paper made (see picture below), but apparently Kevin O'Leary isn't into Fidgeting.

That's about where the story ends.  The reality is that Shark Tank isn't a good fit for a product like Baby Paper and Fidgety Paper.  The Sharks want to take products to the mass market and large retailers because the numbers are bigger, the advertisers are richer and the wow factor is greater.  

We have met many of the entrepreneurs who have made deals on the show.  Never for one moment doubt that they are all out there still working hard.  Hats off to them for their persistence and drive to succeed.

You can check out the edited version of the audition video (we removed all financial information).  A very special shout-out toXpress Video Productions for producing & editing the video on a moments notice and to Building Blocks Toy Store  for letting us use their store!